Welcome to The Briefcase

Commentary and analysis of Ohio criminal law and whatever else comes to mind, served with a dash of snark.  Continue Reading »

×

Case Update

Nothing out of the US Supreme Court this past week, except a decision sure to cheese off the Save the Whales Foundation:  in Winter v. National Resources Defense Council, the Court upheld the Navy's right to conduct sonar excercises in the Pacific, despite claims of environmentalists that such exercises might harm marine life.  Good news for Flipper:  while the Court didn't decide one of the underlying issues -- whether the Navy had to prepare an environmental impact statement -- the Navy's going to do so anyway. 

Nothing of significance out of Columbus, either, except that the Supreme Court's agreed to determine whether the add-on one-to-ten year sentence for Repeat Violender Offender specifications survived Foster.  I had several posts a couple years back claiming that they didn't, but several courts, including the 8th, have come to a contrary conclusion, and there's language in Foster and some subsequent Supreme Court cases which muddies up the waters.  So, a year or so from now, we'll finally get a resolution of that.  Maybe; that same issue, except in the context of Major Drug Offender specifications, was present in another appeal that just got dismissed by the court after being pending for ten months.

On to the courts of appeals, which don't get the opportunity to duck cases that way...

Civil.  Attorney did not have authority to enter into settlement; good discussion of when a settlement is enforceable in this 8th District case... 9th District says that father had the burden to prove that he was not underemployed for purposes of determining child support... Hybrid representation (litigant with counsel also seeks to act pro se) banned in criminal cases, 8th District says that court could prohibit hybrid representation in divorce case as well, even where litigant was an attorney... 12th District holds that "terms" of child's living arrangement under shared parenting agreement can be modified without a showing of change of circumstances, requires only that it be in best interest of child, says that court should have considered father's motion to deny issuance of child's passport...

Criminal.  8th District upholds court's decision to close courtroom to public during informant's testimony, good discussion of factors involved... Buyer's remorse:  pro se defendant argues trial judge shouldn't have let him represent himself, 2nd District says judge properly advised him of consequences, affirms... 9th District says claim of actual innocence is not a basis for postconviction relief... 12th District holds that guilty plea waives claim of ineffective assistance of counsel for failing to raise speedy trial claim...

Alternative theories.  From the 1st District's opinion in State v. Miller:  "Miller came to Perkins's old apartment, either to collect a drug debt or to check on a puppy that Perkins was caring for."

Things you won't see on Law and Order:  From the 8th District's decision in State v. Robinson:

In the instant case, the state's first witness was Cleveland police officer Scott Miller, who testified about evidence bags of heroin and marijuana found as evidence at the scene of a crime. Subsequent to Miller's testimony, however, the prosecutor realized that this was evidence from a different case and had nothing to do with appellant. The mistake was traced to the Cleveland Police Department, who inadvertently used the same report number for these drugs as the crack cocaine that appellant is charged with possessing and trafficking.

Search

Recent Entries

  • February 23, 2018
    Marsy's Law -- Restitution
    How the Victim's Rights Amendment passed last November affects restitution
  • February 20, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    A search decision, more "policies," and why a seminar for muni court judges on taking pleas might be a good idea
  • February 14, 2018
    Two more to death row
    A couple of death penalty decisions from the Ohio Supreme Court
  • February 12, 2018
    En banc on sentencing
    The 8th looks at the appellate court's role in reviewing sentences
  • February 8, 2018
    SCOTUS and the Fourth
    A couple of upcoming Supreme Court decisions on search and seizure
  • February 5, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    The benefits of appealing muni court cases, lecture time, and when you absolutely, positively, cannot raise arguments about manifest weight and sufficiency
  • February 2, 2018
    Friday Roundup
    School specs and sovereign citizens
  • January 31, 2018
    A tale of three cases
    The Ohio Supreme Court decides one case, and decides not to decide two others
  • January 29, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    Getting rid of an attorney, no contest pleas, and probation conditions
  • January 26, 2018
    Friday Roundup
    Information society. Last week I did a post about Aaron Judge and the lack of hard data in the field of criminal law. We have mainly anecdotal information on what kinds of sentences judges hand down, we have no idea...