Welcome to The Briefcase

Commentary and analysis of Ohio criminal law and whatever else comes to mind, served with a dash of snark.  Continue Reading »

×

Case Update

Nothing of significance in the US Supreme Court this week.  Down in Columbus, in addition to State v. Sarkozy, which I discussed on Friday, the Ohio Supreme Court decided Pruszynski v. Reeves, a decision significantly clarifying the law on prejudgment interest.  Although a number of courts have decided that a hearing is only required if the trial court is going to grant interest, the Supreme Court says no:  you've got to hold a hearing either way.  The trial court does have some latitude in exactly what type of hearing to conduct, but there's got to be one.  And in State ex rel Stucco Inc. v. Ind. Comm., the Court holds that even if an employee is validly terminated, if he's on temporary total disability at the time, he's entitled to continue collecting it.

On to the courts of appeals...

Civil.  8th District holds that lower court properly held defendant in contempt for failing to allow visitation, but erred in not allowing her to purge contempt, but dissent probably has better argument that that's not required... 6th District reverses judgment for malicious prosecution, holds that wife's threat to husband to "rip your balls off" constituted probable cause for arrest for threatening domestic violence.  I'll say... 9th District holds that operation of group home by Children's Services is a "governmental," not "proprietary" function under sovereign immunity statutes... 2nd District holds court erred in giving wife more than her share of her pension to provide her support, says proper procedure is to award spousal support for that purpose...

Criminal.  6th District holds that trial court did not give improper weight in sentencing to defendant's juvenile convictions, which consisted of -- count 'em -- six felonies and sixteen misdemeanors... 9th District rules that three-time refusal to allow drunk driving suspect to call her attorney before taking breathalyzer test didn't require suppression of test for violation of right to counsel under 6th Amendment or RC 2935.20... Somewhat befuddling ruling on collateral estoppel as part of double jeopardy in this 10th District decision:  acquittal of agg robbery and firearms specification in first trial didn't bar introduction of evidence of gun in second trial on rape charge, but it was error for trial court not to instruct jury that evidence of gun couldn't be considered as "force"... 11th District holds that three-year delay in serving indictment violated defendant's constitutional right to speedy trial... 4th District also throws out conviction for violation of speedy trial, says time not tolled for motion to suppress because judge took over a year to rule on it; part of reason for delay was that one of the county judges had been indicted... 8th District affirms that after bindover, juvenile can be indicted for additional crimes as long as they arose from same transaction...

Bullshit Traffic Stop of the Week:  3rd District upholds stop based on officer's determination that license plate and license plate light were "awfully dirty."

Search

Recent Entries

  • February 23, 2018
    Marsy's Law -- Restitution
    How the Victim's Rights Amendment passed last November affects restitution
  • February 20, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    A search decision, more "policies," and why a seminar for muni court judges on taking pleas might be a good idea
  • February 14, 2018
    Two more to death row
    A couple of death penalty decisions from the Ohio Supreme Court
  • February 12, 2018
    En banc on sentencing
    The 8th looks at the appellate court's role in reviewing sentences
  • February 8, 2018
    SCOTUS and the Fourth
    A couple of upcoming Supreme Court decisions on search and seizure
  • February 5, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    The benefits of appealing muni court cases, lecture time, and when you absolutely, positively, cannot raise arguments about manifest weight and sufficiency
  • February 2, 2018
    Friday Roundup
    School specs and sovereign citizens
  • January 31, 2018
    A tale of three cases
    The Ohio Supreme Court decides one case, and decides not to decide two others
  • January 29, 2018
    What's Up in the 8th
    Getting rid of an attorney, no contest pleas, and probation conditions
  • January 26, 2018
    Friday Roundup
    Information society. Last week I did a post about Aaron Judge and the lack of hard data in the field of criminal law. We have mainly anecdotal information on what kinds of sentences judges hand down, we have no idea...