Recent Posts

  • Friday Roundup
  • Once bitten, twice shy
  • False confessions
  • Case Update - Back in the Saddle Edition
  • Reconsidering Colon
  • Just chillin’…
  • Max Consec
  • The Feds come calling
  • Case Update
  • Friday Roundup


  • Categories

  • Civil
  • Criminal
  • Constitutional
  • Potpourri
  • Rants


  • Archives

  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007
  • February 2007
  • January 2007
  • December 2006
  • November 2006
  • October 2006
  • September 2006
  • August 2006
  • July 2006
  • June 2006
  • May 2006


  • July 31, 2006

    July 31st, 2006

    Got a lot of work to catch up on today, so just a short note… 

    Back in 2004, the Ohio Supreme Court, in Ohio v. Jordan, held that a trial court had to apprise the defendant of post-release controls (PRC) both at the sentencing hearing and in the sentencing journal entry.  Earlier this year, it followed up that decision by holding, in Hernandez v. Kelly, that if the Court failed to do that, PRC couldn’t be imposed. 

    This issue often arises on appeal, and the appellate court routinely remands the case for resentencing, telling the judge to get it right.  But what happens if there’s not an appeal?  As I pointed out a couple months back, failure to notify a defendant of PRC precludes a later conviction for escape.  If that was questionable before Hernandez, it certainly isn’t afterward.  But the sentencing court couldn’t correct the error on its own, because it loses jurisdiction to modify sentencing after the defendant is sent to the institution.

    So a couple of weeks ago, new section RC 2929.191 went into effect, allowing the trial courts to correct a sentencing entry to include PRC.  The court has to hold a hearing in order to do that, at which the defendant must be present, either in person or through the magic of video.

    One Response to “July 31, 2006”

    1. Brian McGraw Says:

      Russ:

      Can you point me in the direction of a copy of 2929.191 (not yet at Anderson’s)? Are there any time constraints regarding when such a hearing must occur? Can they bring the guy in a week before he gets released from prison (or even after he’s out) to clean up a PRC mess?

      Let me guess…the released prisoner asserts that he was never advised of PRC and the next thing that happens is that he is before his sentencing judge being advised of PRC.

      Lots of issues with this PRC business currently. Example: PRC is mentioned in the sentencing journal entry but was not mentioned by the judge at the sentencing (a fairly common mistake-the judge doesn’t say it but the bailiff throws it in the JE because he/she always puts it in there). We lawyers at sentencing probably need to listen for this (which we don’t always do very well) and advise our client before he heads off to LCI.

      Also, arguing PRC defects was fairly common in an appeal. Now, you probably shouldn’t raise it.

    Leave a Reply


    Search Posts




    Court Links

    Cuyahoga County
    Court of Appeals
    Common Pleas-General
    Common Pleas-Domestic
    Common Pleas-Juvenile
    Common Pleas-Probate

    Ohio Courts
    Ohio Supreme Court
    Geauga County Common Pleas
    Lake County Common Pleas
    Lorain County Common Pleas
    Summit County Common Pleas
    Links to all Ohio Courts
    Ohio Revised Code

    Federal Courts
    US Supreme Court
    6th Circuit Court of Appeals
    Ohio Northern District
    Ohio Southern District



    Law Blogs

    Sentencing Law & Policy
    Volokh Conspiracy
    Appellate Law & Practice
    CrimLaw
    Grits for Breakfast
    Confrontation Blog
    CrimProf Blog
    How Appealing
    Crime and Consequences
    Drug War Rant
    A Stitch in Haste
    Overlawyered
    Balkinization
    Inside Opinions: Legal Blogs
    ScotusBlog

    Ohio Law blogs

    Cleveland Law Library
    6th Circuit - Criminal
    6th Circuit - General
    Ohio Personal Injury Lawyer
    Ohio Family Law Blog
    OACDL
    CCDLA

    Blogfinder

    Law Blog Metrics



    lawyer blogs